CARE Team Liability: Reducing Legal Risk in Higher Education
Updated: Nov 11

Families and the court system are increasingly pressuring institutions of higher education to take responsibility for their students’ well-being and to protect them from harm. In 2018, the Supreme Court of Massachusetts, in the matter of Nguyen v. MIT, found that MIT was not liable for Mr. Nguyen’s suicide, but stated that in other cases, colleges may have an obligation to prevent suicides and may be sued for failing to do so. Courts now analyze a school’s liability by looking at whether a school acted reasonably under the circumstances and/or whether the tragic incident, a shooting or a student suicide, for example, was foreseeable.
In response to the tragic shootings at Virginia Tech University (2007) and Northern Illinois University (2008), and the subsequent lawsuits alleging the institution’s responsibility, colleges and universities have created teams, such as a CARE team, to address concerning, disruptive, and/or dangerous student behaviors on campus. However, the potential exposure to legal liability, specifically, tort liability for the institution, does not end with the creation of such a team. This blog post features several essential risk management tools to minimize potential liability of the CARE team and individual team members.
Documentation can allow a CARE team to monitor which intervention strategies are recommended to a student, and whether the intervention was successful. Records should be securely kept and managed by database software that enables tracking of student behavior over time. The team should also have protocols as to how to incorporate handwritten notes or other hard copy documents into the online system. A written record can improve a team’s overall functioning and minimize potential liability exposure. Documentation can help the CARE team show that it acted reasonably under the circumstances.
Concerns about potential liability may prevent some teams from adequately documenting their practices, protocols, and responses. Minutes taken during CARE team meetings and notes taken by the individual CARE team members are potentially subject to disclosure in a future lawsuit. However, there are certain exceptions under relevant state and federal laws, including HIPAA and FERPA. Further, documentation is essential to any defense in a future lawsuit.
Institutions can further mitigate their risk exposure through the appropriate use of parental notification policies. It is important to know when it is best to notify a parent/guardian and what information to provide. The bottom line is that family involvement can be an asset to a CARE team when used appropriately. Families can offer valuable support to a student and can provide history and an understanding of a student’s patterns of behavior to the CARE team.
While an attorney might not serve as a permanent member of a CARE team, the team should consult with legal counsel as appropriate. Legal counsel must have experience specific to threat assessment, mental health issues, and related matters that impact CARE team functions. Legal counsel can provide guidance on the relevant statutes that impact an intervention, such as FERPA, HIPAA, and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Counsel can review institutional policies and CARE team procedures to ensure compliance with relevant laws. Counsel can provide advice on legal issues that affect the team’s function, such as permissible information sharing and documentation practices, thereby empowering the team to take actions and share information when there is a fear (whether real or perceived) of legal issues.
Overall, the CARE team and individual team members should always act in accordance with school policies and procedures. Once a CARE team member acts, or fails to act, outside of the set protocols, they are open to individual liability in a potential lawsuit. Clear communication with campus faculty, staff, and students about such policies and procedures is essential.

