top of page
Search

The Knock Is the Easy Part: Welfare and Wellness Checks That Help, Not Harm

Nov 12
6 min read

Clenched fist in a brown sleeve pressed against a wall, close-up with a tense, determined mood.

A welfare check can look pretty simple on paper. Someone is worried about a student, somebody goes to the room, there is a knock on the door, and eventually the call gets marked complete. The problem is that the knock may be the easiest decision anyone makes.


I recently presented an InterACTT webinar on welfare and wellness checks with Chief Joe Dooley, a longtime campus public-safety leader and retired Chief of Police at Southern Connecticut State University. We came at the topic from different professional directions, which was useful because these checks often sit right at the intersection of student affairs, BIT/CARE, Residence Life, counseling, and public safety.


Most of our conversation was about everything surrounding the knock. A good response starts with gathering enough information to understand why someone is concerned, then deciding who is best positioned to respond and what that person is actually trying to accomplish. From there, the process has to account for both possibilities at the door: the student answers or they do not. Either way, somebody still has to decide what happens to the concern after everyone leaves.


I still think about a welfare check from earlier in my career involving a veteran student who was struggling with suicidal thoughts. Residence Life and police were involved, and we were doing what campuses often do when we know enough to be concerned but not enough to know exactly what is happening behind a closed door. The student answered and we made contact. The immediate situation ended, but he died by suicide months later.


I don't tell that story because I believe the welfare check failed or because I think a different conversation at the door would necessarily have changed what happened later. Suicide is much more complicated than that. What stayed with me was how little the phrase welfare check completed actually tells us. It tells us an activity occurred. It does not necessarily tell us whether the concern that led us there has been resolved.


Before Anyone Goes to the Door

The request for a welfare check often arrives with a lot of anxiety attached to it. A parent is frightened. A roommate wants someone to act immediately. A faculty member has read an email that does not sound like the student they know. That urgency matters, but it does not relieve us of the need to gather information. We want to understand what changed, when the student was last seen, and what attempts at contact have already been made. Known suicide or violence risk, medical concerns, substance use, access to weapons, and recent losses or disruptions can all change what the next step should look like.


One of the simplest questions in this work may also be one of the most useful: What do we actually know? There is a difference between a parent saying a student has not answered a text since breakfast and a parent saying the student sent a goodbye message and may have access to a firearm. Missing two classes is different from abruptly disappearing from class, work, team practice, and every other normal point of contact after a major loss.


Sometimes those questions confirm that someone needs to go immediately. Other times they change who should respond, what the responder should be prepared for, or whether knocking on a door is actually the best first intervention.


Who Goes Matters

Many campuses have traditionally treated welfare checks as police or public-safety work. There are plenty of circumstances where that makes sense, particularly when there is a credible concern involving violence, weapons, immediate danger, forced entry, or something requiring law-enforcement authority. There are also situations where a uniformed officer does not have to be the first or only option.


Joe and I spent time during the webinar talking about the different roles of public safety, Residence Life, counseling, BIT/CARE, case management, and other campus partners. A student who has stopped responding to an RA presents a different problem from someone who has made a specific threat and may have access to a weapon. Those distinctions are much easier to discuss at 2:00 in the afternoon around a conference table than at 11:20 at night in a residence-hall hallway.


That is why the protocol matters. Campuses should have some shared understanding of when Residence Life can make the first contact, when public safety should lead, and what information responders need before arriving. They should also know which circumstances move the situation beyond a routine welfare check and into a different kind of response. A good protocol does not eliminate judgment. It gives people a better place to start exercising it.


The Door Opens. Now What?

There is an understandable moment of relief when the student answers. They are alive, they are standing in front of us, and often the first thing they say is some version of, “I'm fine.” Sometimes they are. Other times, “I'm fine” means the student would very much like the unexpected group of university employees outside their room to go away.


The original concern should still shape the conversation. A check prompted by suicide concerns requires responders to clarify different things than one prompted by threats toward another person. If the student appears intoxicated, highly agitated, disorganized, or disconnected from what is happening around them, the responder may need to slow the interaction down and adjust rather than pushing forward with a standard script.


Calm, simple, non-confrontational communication is not merely about being nice. The way we approach someone can affect the behavior we are trying to understand. The goal should be more than establishing that the student can answer a door. We need enough information to decide what, if anything, happens next.


And sometimes nobody answers at all. A closed door is not an assessment. The student may be asleep, somewhere else, deliberately avoiding contact, medically incapacitated, or in serious danger. What happens next should depend on what brought us there in the first place rather than the absence of an answer alone.


What Happens After Everyone Leaves?

This may be the part of welfare-check practice I worry about most. The officer clears the call. Residence Life goes back to the desk. Somebody documents that the student was contacted, and everyone returns to whatever was happening before the phone rang. But if the concern was significant enough that we sent people to someone's room late at night, somebody should probably ask what happens the next morning.


The answer may involve BIT/CARE, a case manager, Residence Life, counseling, or another campus partner depending on what happened. Information from the check needs to reach the people responsible for ongoing support when appropriate, and somebody needs to own the decision about follow-up. That answer will not be the same in every case, but the handoff should not be accidental.


That is the part that still takes me back to the veteran student from years ago. The welfare check was one moment in a much longer story, which is true of many of the students who generate these calls. Completed contact and completed intervention are not always the same thing.


Look at the Whole Check

If I were reviewing a campus welfare and wellness check process, I would look at three places: before the knock, at the door, and after the check. Before the knock, I would look at how information is gathered and how the institution determines who responds. At the door, the focus shifts to whether responders have enough training and flexibility to adjust to what they encounter. Afterward, the question becomes where the information goes and who decides whether anything else needs to happen.


That exercise tends to reveal gaps pretty quickly. A campus may have excellent public-safety response but almost no follow-up. Residence Life may be conducting dozens of checks without consistent guidance about when another department should become involved. BIT/CARE may hear about some checks and never know others occurred.


Everyone can be doing reasonable work inside their own lane while nobody is paying much attention to the road connecting them. The student experiences the whole process. Our systems should be able to see it that way too.


We Built Something for This

Many of the questions from the webinar are the same ones that led InterACTT and DPrep Safety to develop the Welfare & Wellness Check Toolkit. The toolkit includes editable policy templates for public safety and Residence Life, a six-stage decision rubric, legal cases and considerations, twelve campus scenarios, and a facilitator guide for using those scenarios with your team.


The goal is not to make every welfare check identical. It is to give campuses a more consistent way to think through the decisions surrounding them. The toolkit is available in the Subscribe & Shop section at InterACTT.org, along with our other practical resources and membership options.


The next time someone asks your campus to conduct a welfare check, I would resist making the first question simply, “Who can go knock?” Start instead with the reason for the check, the information the responder needs, what you are hoping to learn from the contact, and who will own the concern once the immediate interaction is over. If those pieces are unclear, that's probably where the work starts.


 
 

Comments

I'm a paragraph. Click here to add your own text and edit me. It's easy.

bottom of page