top of page
Search

Vermont's Bell-to-Bell Cellphone Ban: What Are We Learning?

Nov 10
3 min read

Updated: Nov 11

Teen girl with headphones checks phone on a stairwell, with other students in the background and a red 5 on the wall.

A middle school student abruptly stopped in the middle of the main hallway stairwell, looked up to the second floor, down to the first floor, and then pulled out her cellphone, quickly scrolling through her phone. What she didn’t do was look across to the main lobby, where I was standing watching this blatant violation of school policy unfold. I walked quietly to the bottom of the stairs. The student never looked up, did not hear me walk toward her, or show any evidence of being aware of her surroundings.


I quietly asked if she needed to be on her “burner” phone right now. She immediately got a little defensive, saying, “I am allowed to call home,” something she was clearly not doing and wouldn't need to do in the middle of a stairwell. The student dropped her phone into her pocket and walked down the hallway.


What made this exchange interesting is that it is the first time I have seen a student with a cellphone since the school year started. Vermont adopted a bell-to-bell cellphone ban beginning with the 2026–27 school year, with our school putting the ban in place voluntarily last school year. It has been months since I saw a student with a cellphone.


The typical procedure is for students to put their personal cellphones in a designated location in the classroom during the school day. Some classes have individual bins or plastic hanging pockets; other teachers require students to keep them in lockers. If there is an emergency, students can access their phones to call home. Parents call the main office to reach their student or leave a cellphone message the student can retrieve later in the day.


Proponents of this ban cite concerns about the social isolation that comes with high cellphone use, the increase in mental health issues such as depression and anxiety, and concerns about cyberbullying (Peterson, 2026). Increased absenteeism and dropping grades have been highlighted as possible outcomes of unmonitored cellphones in public schools.


When the ban is enforced, schools typically report an increase in suspensions and/or other disciplinary actions for “breaking the ban.”

What the data tell us is that school suspension rates drop back toward previous levels the following school year. A large Florida school district reported improved learning (as measured by test scores) along with a reduction in unexcused absenteeism (Education Next, 2026). Other states are beginning to report on the effects of these bans. A nationwide study of over 5,000 schools also found an increase in disciplinary actions during the first year of ban enforcement, with those increases fading over time (NBER, 2026).


What we don’t know yet is whether the ban will improve mental health, reduce social isolation, or reduce cyberbullying. Anecdotally, the halls are noisier, students are talking to each other in the lunchroom, and suspensions for violating the ban are limited to those who bring in a second phone that they do not put in the designated location during the day.


Should I have reported the student in the stairwell? My role as a school psychologist means I probably should have taken the phone and returned it to the teacher's classroom with the student. I was so surprised to see a student sneaking a cellphone at school. I didn't even think about what to do when the student had already walked away.


References

National Bureau of Economic Research. (2026). The Effects of School Phone Bans: National Evidence From Lockable Pouches. NBER Working Paper Series.https://www.nber.org/papers/w35132

Education


Next. (2026). Can Banning Cellphones Save Student Learning? Vol. 26, No. 2.https://www.educationnext.org/can-banning-cellphones-save-student-learning-evidence-florida-mandate/


Harvard Kennedy School. (2026). Many States Are Banning Cellphones in Schools. Is It Working? Interview with public policy expert Paul Peterson.https://www.hks.harvard.edu/faculty-research/policy-topics/education-training-labor/many-states-are-banning-cellphones-schools

 
 

Comments

I'm a paragraph. Click here to add your own text and edit me. It's easy.

bottom of page